BBB Top Prospect Countdown: Official Breakdown

Now that our prospect list is officially finished, I decided to release the official breakdown of our prospect rankings by our writers. Here, you can see the exact breakdown and discrepancies between writers. Which writer do you think has the best prospect list? Leave us your feedback, and enjoy!
BBB Prospect Rankings per Writer

RANK
CHAD
JULIAN
SAMMY
JAMES
PHIL
1.
Aaron Judge
Aaron Judge
Aaron Judge
Aaron Judge
Aaron Judge
2.
Gary Sanchez
Gary Sanchez
Jorge Mateo
Jorge Mateo
Jorge Mateo
3.
Jorge Mateo
Jorge Mateo
James Kaprielian
Gary Sanchez
Gary Sanchez
4.
James Kaprielian
James Kaprielian
Gary Sanchez
James Kaprielian
James Kaprielian
5.
Domingo Acevedo
Domingo Acevedo
Domingo Acevedo
Dustin Fowler
Rob Refsnyder
6.
Rob Refsnyder
Rob Refsnyder
Ian Clarkin
Domingo Acevado
Jacob Lindgren
7.
Dustin Fowler
Wilkerman Garcia
Robert Refsnyder
Ian Clarkin
Ian Clarkin
8.
Slade Heathcott
Dustin Fowler
Wilkerman Garcia
Wilkerman Garcia
Domingo Acevedo
9.
Wilkerman Garcia
Brady Lail
Jacob Lindgren
Jacob Lindgren
Wilkerman Garcia
10.
Brady Lail
Drew Finley
Dustin Fowler
Luis Torrens
Brady Lail
11.
Ian Clarkin
Ian Clarkin
Slade Healthcott
Tyler Wade
Dustin Fowler
12.
Jacob Lindgren
Jacob Lindgren
Luis Torrens
Slade Heathcott
Slade Heathcott
13.
Drew Finley
Slade Heathcott
Brady Lail
Bryan Mitchell
Bryan Mitchell
14.
Luis Torrens
Bryan Mitchell
Mason Williams
Mason Williams
Luis Torrens
15.
Tyler Wade
Luis Torrens
James Pazos
Rob Refsynder
Tyler Wade
16.
Bryan Mitchell
Tyler Wade
Tyler Wade
Brady Lail
Mason Williams
17.
Mason Williams
Mason Williams
Chance Adams
Hoy Jun Park
Drew Finley
18.
Chance Adams
Chance Adams
Drew Finley
Chance Adams
Chance Adams
19.
James Pazos
Hoy Jun Park
Jonathan Holder
Drew Finley
Luis Cessa
20.
Thairo Estrada
Thairo Estrada
Hoy Jun Park
Luis Cessa
Abiatal Avelino
21.
Jonathan Holder
Jonathan Holder
Thairo Estrada
Jon Holder
Ty Hensley
22.
Luis Cessa
Luis Cessa
Kyle Holder
James Pazos
James Pazos
23.
Hoy Jun Park
Abiatal Avelino
Cale Coshow
Ty Hensley
Ben Gamel
24.
Ty Hensley
James Pazos
Bryan Mitchell
Abiatal Avelino
Tyler Austin
25.
Ben Gamel
Ty Hensley
Ben Gamel
Ben Gamel
Jonathan Holder
26.
Abiatal Avelino
Ben Gamel
Abiatal Avelino
Cale Coshow
Hoy Jun Park
27.
Nick Rumbelow
Miguel Andujar
Ty Hensley
Austin DeCarr
Austin DeCarr
28.
Miguel Andujar
Vicente Campos
Luis Cessa
Vicente Campos
Vicente Campos
29.
Cale Coshow
Cale Coshaw
Nick Rumbelow
Trey Amburgey
Nick Rumbelow
30.
Austin Decarr
Nick Rumbelow
Tyler Austin
Miguel Andujar
Miguel Andujar
31.
Johnny Barbato
Trey Amburgey
Trey Amburgery
Tyler Austin
Johnny Barbato
32.
Tyler Austin
Austin Decarr
Austin DeCarr
Leonardo Molina
Domingo German
33.
Trey Amburgey
Leonardo Molina
Vicente Campos
Johnny Barbato
Jordan Montgomery
34.
Kyle Holder
Jeff Degano
Miguel Andujar
Kyle Holder
Kyle Holder
35.
Chaz Hebert
Chaz Hebert
Jordan Montgomery
Domingo German
Jeff Degano

BBB Collaborative Rankings
(CR=Chad, JB=Julian, SC=Sammy, JG=James, PA=Phil)
*=Not ranked by everyone
N/A=Not included in person’s top 35

(Rank) Player
CR Rank
JB Rank
SC Rank
JG Rank
PA Rank
Avg.
(1) A. Judge
1
1
1
1
1
1.0
(2) J. Mateo
3
3
2
2
2
2.4
(3) G. Sanchez
2
2
4
3
3
2.8
(4) J. Kaprielian
4
4
3
4
4
3.8
(5) D. Acevedo
5
5
5
6
8
5.8
(6) R. Refsnyder
6
6
7
15
5
7.8
(7) D. Fowler
7
8
10
5
11
8.2
(8) W. Garcia
9
7
8
8
9
8.2
(9) I. Clarkin
11
11
6
7
7
8.4
(10) J. Lindgren
12
12
9
9
6
9.6
(11) S. Heathcott
8
13
11
12
12
11.2
(12) B. Lail
10
9
13
16
10
11.6
(13) L. Torrens
14
15
12
10
14
13.0
(14) T. Wade
15
16
16
11
15
14.6
(15) D. Finley
13
10
18
19
17
15.4
(16) M. Williams
17
17
14
14
16
15.6
(17) B. Mitchell
16
14
24
13
13
16.0
(18) C. Adams
18
18
17
18
18
17.8
(19) T. Estrada
20
20
21
N/A
N/A
20.3*
(20) J. Pazos
19
24
15
22
22
20.4
(21) H.J. Park
23
19
20
17
26
21.0
(22) J. Holder
21
21
19
21
25
21.4
(23) L. Cessa
22
22
28
20
19
22.2
(24) T. Hensley
24
25
27
23
21
24.0
(25) B. Gamel
25
26
25
25
23
24.8
(26) A. Avelino
26
23
26
24
20
25.8
(27) C. Coshow
29
29
23
26
N/A
26.75*
(28) N. Rumbelow
27
30
29
N/A
29
28.75*
(29) V. Campos
N/A
28
33
28
28
29.25*
(30) T. Austin
32
N/A
30
31
24
29.25*
(31) A. Decarr
30
32
32
27
27
29.6
(32) M. Andujar
28
27
34
30
30
29.8
(32) T. Amburgey
33
31
31
29
N/A
31
(33) K. Holder
34
N/A
22
34
34
31*
(34) J. Barbato
31
N/A
N/A
33
31
31.6*
(35) L. Molina
N/A
33
N/A
32
N/A
32.5
(36) D. German
N/A
N/A
N/A
35
32
34.0*
(37) J. Montgomery
N/A
N/A
35
N/A
33
34*
(38) J. Degano
N/A
34
N/A
N/A
35
34.5*
(39) C. Hebert
35
35
N/A
N/A
N/A
35*

You can view our COMPLETED top 30 list with links to our breakdowns HERE.


Follow Chad on twitter @Chad_Rain
Follow Julian on twitter @JuneYank6
Follow Sammy on twitter @SCriscitello11
Follow James on twitter @The_Real_Grande
Follow Phil on twitter @PhilAkre
Follow the BBB on twitter @BronxBomberBlog

Comments