Brett Gardner trade ideas based off the Adam Eaton trade

Just last week, the Washington Nationals gave up a boat load of top prospects to acquire outfielder Adam Eaton from the Chicago White Sox. The Nationals gave up number one prospect Lucas Giolito, number three prospect Reynaldo Lopez and number six prospect Dane Dunning. While many around baseball thought that the Nationals gave up too much, the Yankees and their fans should rejoice because the trade made Brett Gardner’s value go way up. While Eaton has had a higher WAR than Gardner over the years, Gardner does have an All-Star nod and a gold glove to boot, something Eaton doesn’t have. Because the Nationals gave up their number one, three and six prospects, I decided to do some unrealistic hypotheticals and took the number one, three and six prospects from teams that might line up for a Gardner trade. Still, it is important to note that Gardner is not likely to get the same return that Eaton received, but here's what some trades could look like if he did, just for kicks.


Baltimore Orioles
  • No. 1: Cody Sedlock (RHP)
    2016: 9 G, 9 GS, 0-1, 3.00 ERA, 25 K, 27 IP (class-A short)
  • No. 3: Hunter Harvey (RHP)
    2016: 5 G, 5 GS, 0-1, 2.13 ERA, 18 K, 12.2 IP (Rookie-Low A)
  • No. 6: Ryan Mountcastle (SS)
    2016: 115 G, .281 BA, 10 HR, 51 RBI, 5 SB (single-A)
The first thing I think is that this trade would never happen because the Orioles are in the same division, even though Brian Cashman said he is willing to trade with Baltimore. While the return of two starting pitchers would be nice, the Yankees really don’t need another shortstop prospect. But, since Mountcastle had a pretty nice season in Single A, you can always stock up on talent where available.

Detroit Tigers
  • No. 1: Matt Manning (RHP)
    2016: 10 G, 10 GS, 0-2, 3.99 ERA, 46 K, 29.1 IP (Rookie)
  • No. 3: Christin Stewart (OF)
    2016: 128 G, .255 BA, 30 HR, 87 RBI, 3 SB (single-A & double-A)
  • No. 6: Kyle Funkhouser (RHP)
    2016: 13 G, 13 GS, 0-2, 2.65 ERA, 34 K, 37.1 IP (class-A short)
Now this is a very good package. This package would include two good pitching prospects and an outfielder who hit 30 home runs in 128 games between Single A and Double A. A left handed hitter with that kind of pop in Yankee Stadium is deadly. Manning is the #66 prospect on’s top 100 so this package would be a nice haul.

San Francisco Giants
  • No. 1: Christian Arroyo (INF)
    2016: 119 G, .274 BA, 3 HR, 49 RBI, 1 SB (double-A)
  • No. 3: Chris Shaw (1B)
    2016: 132 G, .267 BA, 21 HR, 85 RBI, 0 SB (double-A)
  • No. 6: Aramis Garcia (C)
    2016: 47 G, .253 BA, 2 HR, 24 RBI, 1 SB (Rookie-High A)

Now this package might be the least logical because it doesn’t include any pitching which the Yankees desperately need. The Yankees also have (hopefully) the long term pieces for catcher, first base and the infield and therefore are not a necessity. Perhaps the Yankees would ask for pitchers such as Tyler Beede and Sam Coonrod.

Texas Rangers
  • No. 1: Yohander Mendez (LHP)
    2016: 24 G, 21 GS, 12-3, 2.19 ERA, 113 K, 111 IP (Minors)
    2016: 2 G, 0-0, 18.00 ERA,  0 K, 3 IP (MLB)
  • No. 3: Leody Taveras (OF)
    2016: 73 G, .271 BA, 1 HR, 33 RBI, 18 SB (Rookie, Low A)
  • No. 6: Ariel Jurado (RHP)
    2016: 24 G, 22 GS, 8-6, 3.66 ERA, 106 K, 123 IP (High A-Double A)
This is also a very good package of prospects. Mendez, who is ranked #56 on’s top 100 prospects, had a very good season in the minors and is the only prospect on this list to reach the Majors, pitching three innings for the Rangers in 2016. Taveras doesn’t really stand out to me because he doesn’t have a stand out tool, but he might be useful as a fourth outfielder and maybe a pinch runner if he can work on his stolen base ability and at only 17 Taveras has plenty of room to grow.

Now once again, these are just blueprints based off of the Nationals-White Sox trade and both sides would probably offer/ask for different players. The Eaton trade set the bar high and the Yankees need to cash in on Gardner while his value is sky high.

Article by: Julian Bussells


Popular posts from this blog

Introducing Bronx Bomber Bets: BBBets 9/23

An Unofficial Guide to Food Options at Yankee Stadium

Frankie Crosetti: “King of Rings”